A Conservative MP has come under fire after suggesting that those in the south of England prefer ballet and opera while northerners are more likely to enjoy football.
Former minister Jake Berry made the comparison as he warned ‘northern culture’ is being hit by Covid-19 and pressed the Government to intervene to ‘save’ football clubs.
Berry, whose previous Government position included the northern powerhouse brief, compared Accrington Stanley FC to the Royal Ballet as he insisted action is required from Westminster to help protect clubs that are the ‘cornerstone’ of communities.
But former England and Leicester City footballer Gary Lineker wrote on Twitter: ‘Yeah, no-one lives and breathes football down sarrrfff.’
He added the face with rolling eyes emoji, while shadow sports minister Alison McGovern also wrote: ‘Ey up northerners. This Tory thinks we don’t have culture oop narth.’
Northern Ballet, based in Leeds, expressed disappointment at Berry’s comments and claimed he was perpetuating ‘tropes that culture in the north is of less value than that in London’.
Members of the public responded by reminding Berry of Lee Hall’s story of Billy Elliot, a coal miner’s son in County Durham who discovers his passion for ballet against his father’s wishes.
Former Minister Jake Berry, MP for Rossendale and Darwen, made the comments as MPs debated support for the economy in the north of England
In response to Berry’s comments Gary Lineker, the former England footballer from Leicester, hit back: ‘Yeah, no-one lives and breathes football down sarrrfff’
Northern Ballet, based in Leeds, expressed disappointment at Berry’s comments and claimed he was perpetuating ‘tropes that culture in the north is of less value’
Shadow sports minister Alison McGovern also wrote: ‘Ey up northerners. This Tory thinks we don’t have culture oop narth’
Jeff Oakley tweeted: ‘Has he not seen Billy Elliot?’
While Francis Ho tweeted: ‘Jake Berry MP seems to think he is Billy Elliot’s dad’.
Matt Hemley tweeted: ‘This guy clearly hasn’t seen Billy Elliot.’
The south of England is home to several football clubs, including Arsenal and Watford, while Leeds-based Opera North is among the other cultural organisations beyond the Watford Gap.
Berry, who leads the Northern Research Group of more than 50 Tory backbenchers representing northern constituencies, made his remarks as MPs debated support for the economy in the north of England.
Members of the public took to Twitter to point out an obvious example; the story of Billy Elliot, a coal miner’s son in Northern England who discovers his passion for ballet
Speaking in Westminster Hall, Liverpool-born Berry, MP for Rossendale and Darwen, said: ‘First of all is the hit that northern culture has taken from this Covid crisis.
‘For many people who live in London and the south of England, things like the opera house and ballet will be at the heart of their culture.
‘But for many of us in the north it is our local football club – our Glyndebourne or Royal Ballet or Royal Opera House or Royal Shakespeare Company will be Blackburn Rovers, Accrington Stanley, Barrow, Carlisle or Sunderland.
‘I’d just say to the minister I think there is a time now where if you look at the argument going on between the EFL and the Premier League, the time has come where the Government must seek to intervene to unblock this to save local football clubs across the north of England – many of which are the cornerstone of our communities and at the heart of our culture.
Wendy Smith of Prefab Sprout tweeted that she found her feet in the music industry due to the cultural venues of her childhood in the north east including Dorman Museum, Middlesbrough
Conductor Music Director at Northern Ballet Jonathan Lo tweeted in response to Berry’s comments: ‘This is not okay – some of the country’s finest art is created in the north’
‘I hope that the minister will reflect on that during the debate.’
Treasury minister Kemi Badenoch did not address Berry’s football plea in her reply to the debate, acknowledging the north of England has been a ‘hotbed’ of energy, ideas and creativity for centuries.
Northern Ballet, writing on Twitter, said: ‘We are disappointed that an MP and former government minister continues to perpetuate tropes that culture in the north is of less value than that in London.
‘In the same way that sporting clubs are of great importance to many people throughout the country, including in the south, culture is equally important to a huge percentage of people in the north.
Members of the public took to Twitter to criticise the comments made by the MP with one commenting ‘This shows how far removed MP’s are from the people in the North’
‘Our home city of Leeds is the only city outside of London to have its own resident ballet, opera and theatre companies.
‘Culture being produced in the north is of world-class quality, vibrant and innovative, and contributes greatly to both society and the economy.
‘We hope that one day this will be recognised by all.’
Berry later released a statement in which he stressed the need to help football clubs on the ‘brink of a financial collapse’.
He said: ‘No-one is saying football doesn’t exist in the south or that ballet doesn’t exist in the north.
‘And no-one is saying that a thriving football league is more important than a thriving arts sector.
‘What we are saying is that many of our working communities in the north are built around our football clubs and, disproportionately, those clubs now find themselves on the precipice of financial collapse and supporters will be rightly asking the question why they too are not being given financial assistance through this crisis.’
Wendy Smith of Prefab Sprout tweeted: ‘I’ve never been to a football match but I have been in a North East band that sold millions of records worldwide.
‘I got there through being involved in cultural venues as a child/ young person, such as Dorman Museum, Middlesbrough Town Hall & Dancecity #NorthEast #BillyElliot.’